This Week in Peterborough: 1885


The courthouse in Regina, District of Saskatchewan, during the trial of Louis Riel in July of 1885. (Library & Archives Canada, MIKAN No. 3194526)


As 1885 drew to a close, Canadians in Peterborough and elsewhere could look back on a momentous year in the country.  The contentious Canadian Pacific Railway, which we have dropped in on numerous times in recent editions of this series, had finally been completed, just in time to ship troops to what is now Saskatchewan to put down the North-West Rebellion.  The uprising’s leader, Louis Riel, had been hanged on November 16th, infuriating a large chunk of French Canada.  The anger, combined with stern measures to control a smallpox outbreak that killed 3000 people in Montreal, resulted in serious rioting in that city.   In the words of the December 31st Peterborough Examiner, “[1885’s] doings will occupy no meagre or uninteresting niche in the annals of our history.”

Click on for debate over the Rebellion, a post office fight gone religious, and of course, New Year’s festivities!

The Northwest Rebellion was over and done with by late December.  However, the wrangling over who was at fault for the revolt, and whether Riel’s death sentence had been justified, continued, and these debates were mirrored in the respective editorial stances of Peterborough’s two major newspapers.  The Examiner, while praising the “true patriotism, prowess and skill in arms, indomitable energy and perseverance” of the soldiers who put down the revolt, also had considerable sympathy for the Metis and for the Natives.  In its December 26th issue, the paper quoted, at length and approvingly, a speech given in Orillia by longtime Liberal Member of Parliament Sir Richard Cartwright, in which he lambasted the governing Conservatives:

“I have said elsewhere… that Louis Riel was very guilty, but also that Louis Riel was infinitely less criminal than the present Premier of Canada and the late Minister of the Department of the Interior.  I say that of the two criminals Riel was far the less guilty… He had never – to do him justice – created any colonization companies to plunder the people.  Riel was but the spark that fired the train which had been laid by the scandalous neglect and mal-administration of Sir John [A. MacDonald] and his associates for seven long years.”


Sir Richard Cartwright, in 1880. (British Library HMNTS 9555.f.7 via Wikimedia Commons)


By contrast, the Peterborough Daily Evening Review unequivocally supported MacDonald’s decision not to commute Riel’s sentence, and attacked Cartwright for hypocrisy and politicization of the rebellion’s aftermath (it is worth noting here that the Review had been founded by Thomas White, who by the 1880s had become a member of MacDonald’s party).  From the paper’s December 31st issue:

“Sir Richard Cartwright accuses Sir John MacDonald of treason, murder, and arson.  The only punishment which he desires inflicted upon him is that he should be driven from power.  Sir Richard must see that if he is honest in his accusation it devolves upon him to take steps to bring the Premier either to prison or the gallows.  It is not a little odd that the punishment he suggests is one that will be to his own material advantage.”

On a brighter and more local note, the Canadian boatmen who had undertaken to accompany the British expedition up the Nile to try to relieve the siege of Khartoum were home, mostly safe and sound.  As we have noted in previous editions of this series, this group, recruited by General Garnet Wolseley on the basis of his experience in dealing with Louis Riel’s first rebellion in 1870, included a number of men Peterborough.  Sixteen Canadians died on the expedition, which arrived too late to save Khartoum and General Charles Gordon, commander of the British garrison there.  The man whose forces took the city, Muhammad Ahmad al-Mahdi, had himself died in June of 1885, and sporadic fighting continued in the region.


The Peterborough Post Office, in 1910. (Toronto Public Library, PC-ON 1632)


The big issue on the Peterborough scene in late 1885 involved the town’s yet-unbuilt post office, with the “yet-unbuilt” bit being the key.  A contentious dispute had arisen over where the building was to be situated, with two groups vying for the right to make the lucrative land sale.  Sectarianism then reared its ugly head — one of the groups, and the early favourite in the bidding, was composed of Roman Catholics, and their opponents called in the Orange Order for support.  The result, according to reports in the papers, was that by the end of December of 1885, 40% of the original $15,000 budget for the project had already been spent in attempts to get one of the groups to back out, all without a single brick being laid.  The post office would eventually open, on the corner of Hunter and Water Streets, but not until 1888.

Apart from that, things were relatively quiet.  James Stevenson was chosen on December 28th as the mayor for 1886, but as there was nobody running against him the decision was made without any fuss at all.


An 1880s curling match. (Image Source)


And that leaves us with only the matter of how Peterborians were ringing in 1886!  There were a number of options available for New Year’s Eve entertainment.  The “lady friends of the Y.M.C.A.” were hosting a reception, as was the Ladies’ Aid Society of George Street Methodist Church.  If those options were not to one’s taste, there was a party being held at the Parlor Roller Rink on Water Street, music to be provided by the Fire Brigade orchestra.  And of course, there was skating and sledding, and as much curling as anyone could want (curling seems very much to have been the Peterborian winter sport of choice at this time – organized hockey would not arrive in the town for at least a few more years).  Finally, popular Vancouverite entertainer Harry Lindley was in town with his company, putting on a production of Sleeping Beauty at the Bradburn Opera House.  An ad in the December 28th Examiner described the play as “[a] Cyclone of Frollicking Fun” and “[a] Carnival of Bewildering Beauty” – high praise indeed!

Because of the format of this series, we have arrived at a sort of odd pass.  Next week’s post will examine the opening days of 1886 — in other words, we’ll be looking at events that took place the week after the ones in this piece.  We will also be looking at them through the lens of daily, not weekly, newspapers – the Examiner had made the switch in 1885, and was by this time putting out six issues a week.

Until then, a very Happy New Year to everyone!




This entry was posted in This Week in Peterborough. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to This Week in Peterborough: 1885

  1. Pingback: This Week in Peterborough: 1896 | Peterboriana

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s